Prudence Island light sits on the east side of Prudence Island.  It’s quite a long way out there if you try to shoot from Aquidneck Island.  The shot above is taken from NEB in Portsmouth.  You can take a ferry out from Bristol that costs ~$7 per person round trip.  The ferry is only there for about 5 minutes while it shuffles passengers for the return trip, so you either have to shoot from the ferry dock or stay for an hour and a half until it returns.

View Prudence Island Light in a larger map